Revision/Clarification of Thoughts on Traditionalist Consecrations
Keywords: sedevacantism, sedeprivationism, episcopal consecration, defect of sacramental intention Sources: Anglican Orders and Defect of Intention. Francis Clark, SJ. 1956. De Ecclesia Christi. Timoteo Zapelena. 1954. De Episcopo. Dominique Bouix. 1859 (First edition). Intervista a Mons. Guérard des Lauriers OP sulla Tesi di Cassiciacum. Sodalitium. Satis Cognitum. Leo XIII. 1896. Theologia Moralis Universa. Pietro Scavini. 1869 (Eleventh ed.). Various testimonies of Doctors Eberhard Heller and Kurt Hiller, published in Einsicht. I’m publishing this post because though I still have doubts about the validity of the episcopal consecrations putatively conferred by Fr. Guérard des Lauriers OP on Fathers Günther Storck and Robert McKenna, I now realize that my prior post on this topic did not offer a convincing enough argument in favor of the doubtfulness of these consecrations. I believe that I presented enough evidence in that post to make a convincing argument that sedeprivationism as a...